Top 8 Best Broiler Pans of 2022 Reviewed with Buying Guide

If you ask any master chef, they will tell you a broiler pan is a must-have as a kitchen utensil. This is because if you want your meals to cook evenly while maintaining its moist state, it needs a certain degree of heat that can be only possible through broiling. 

Therefore, to ensure your meals are evenly cooked, you need to use the best broiler pan. But how do you find the best broiler pan in a market full of many choices?

You will need a review, and that is exactly what this article is about: A review of the top 8 best broiler pans of 2022, their pros and cons, and a buying guide to guide you through your buying process. 

Let’s get started. 

Top 8 Best Broiler Pans of 2022 

Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan

An outstanding quality that makes the Granite Ware exceptional is not the fact that it’s a 3-piece set but the fact that this three-piece set can be used together for a specific purpose. 

The Granite Ware consists of a Bake, Broil, and Grill pan that makes a magic team. 

Whenever you broil or grill, you can use the baking pan to serve as a drip tray for easy cleaning and maintenance. 

What’s more? 

The Granite Ware is dishwasher safe, so you don’t have to worry about the time you will spend scrubbing after use. Its baking pan is also made from porcelain enamel, so you can be guaranteed that none of your meals would stick into the pan, which makes them easy to wash off. 

The Granite Ware bake, broil, and grill pan are equipped with a carbon steel core, so they save energy, heat up faster even when the heat is low. 

The only downside to the Granite Ware is that it has a nonstick coating can that can crack if the pan falls, but you can prevent it from happening by taking extra caution when handling the pan.

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The Granite Ware bake, broil, and grill pan is an easy-to-clean broiler pan,  so if you want easy maintenance, then you can count on the Granite Ware. What I love most about it, though, is the fact that its three-piece set can be harmonized for different purposes, which makes it an extremely versatile tool. Bottom line, the Granite Ware bake, broil, and grill pan is a go-to if you want multi-purpose functionality and easy maintenance.

Norpro Broil/Roast Pan Set

The Nopro 273 Broil and Roast pan set has a non-sticky, sleek internal and surface outlook that makes it stand out from the rest of the broiler pan available in the market. It’s easy to drain grease, soup, and oil from your meal while broiling through its perforated top. 

It also has a small, light-weight, and portable size that makes it easy and convenient to carry anywhere. So if perhaps you want to broil during your outdoor camping, you can conveniently carry your Norpro 273 broil set for all your trips outside the house. 

The Norpro 273 broil set also offers easy maintenance as it is made from complete stainless steel that makes it easy to wash off dirt after use. The stainless steel also makes it resistant to rust and makes it durable for harsh weather conditions. 

The aesthetic highlight of the Norpro 273 broiler pan is the fact that it has a sleek design and long-lasting shining feature that makes it convenient to touch and pleasing to the eyes. 

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The Norpro 273 broiler pan should be your go-to broiler pan if you want easy mobility with your broiler pan. It is small and light-weight and is also aesthetically designed to beautify your kitchen. One factor to note before buying the Norpro 273, however, is that it’s small and only convenient for two servings. 

Range Kleen Broiler Pans

Range Kleen Broiler Pans have two pieces, and one unique, outstanding feature of this broiler pan is its durability. It has been built with a heavy-duty construction which makes it highly suitable for harsh outdoor conditions. 

Its high durability also means that it will last for the long term, so you can rest assured that you will use your broiler set for years without having to get a replacement. 

Another quality that is worthy of note about the Range Kleen broiler pans is they can survive very high heat, up to 1,025 degrees Fahrenheit. So you can go ahead to broil with as much heat as you can, knowing fully well that your broiler pan won’t bend or get damaged. 

The Range Kleen broiler pan is dishwasher safe, thereby offering easy cleaning and maintenance. It is also Teflon coated, so it’s non-sticky which further aids a smooth cleaning process.

The downside I find to the Kleen broiler pan, though, is that its surface tends to discolor permanently after you’ve used it for a while. 

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The Range Kleen broiler pan is a great choice if you are looking for the best Teflon coated broiler pan to give you a smooth cleaning experience. More so, if you are looking for a broiler pan that can stand the test of time and harsh conditions, then you should consider the Kleen broiler pan as it is built with heavy-duty construction. What’s more? It can also stand the test of heat without warping and is dishwasher safe for easy maintenance. 

General Electric Genuine OEM Broiler Pan

The General Electric WB48X10056 is unique for its large surface, making it a perfect match for those who tend to broil food in large quantities.  

It also serves as a dual-purpose pan as it comes in two pieces, making it suitable for baking and broiling. 

You also don’t have to worry about your meals getting gummed on the surface pan because it is non-sticky. More so, its body is coated with non-sticky porcelain, which makes it easy to wash and ensures that heat is evenly distributed across your meals.  

The general electric WB48X10056 provides you with easy maintenance as well, as it is dishwasher safe. It also comes with a rack so you can store your utensils in one space.

However, it requires careful handling as its non-sticky surface tends to come off easily.

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The general electric WB48X10056 is a great choice if you plan to broil at a party or get together for many people. Also, if you cook in large quantities, then it is suitable for you. The general electric WB48X10056 is also a recommended choice if you are looking for the best stainless steel broiling pan with a rack.

Nordic Ware Broiler Pan

The Nordic Ware Non-stick Broiler set comes in a two-piece set and serves as a dual purpose as it can be used as a baking pan and a broiler pan. It’s also durable for long-term use as both pieces are made of three layers, making them longer lasting. 

What’s more? You can be sure of efficient even heat distribution for all your meals as its core is made of carbon steel with two layers of aluminum, which makes them heat faster and highly resistant to high heat, thereby preventing warping. 

You can also maintain your Nordic Ware broiler pan well as it is non-sticky. 

The downside I noticed to the Nordic ware pan is that it has few holes at the pan’s top surface, which makes it more susceptible to clogging. 

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The Nordic ware nonstick broiler pan was built to last. So if you plan to save more money in your next broiler pan purchase, then you should consider the Nordic nonstick broiler pan. 

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan

The Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler pan is definitely one of the best broiler pans you can buy for the money. It has a wide range of unique features that make it functional and convenient for anyone to use it. 

It heats up your meals quickly and distributes heat across your food evenly, so you enjoy a well-cooked meal with your family and loved ones.  

It is also nonstick and dishwasher safe, so you don’t have to go through the process of scrubbing hard and for a long time after you’ve removed use.  

What’s more? 

You can easily drain the oil and excess fat while broiling your meals because its top surface has many vent-type holes. 

It is further built with durable stainless steel to ensure longevity. 

However, apart from all its top functional features, the Whirlpool 4396923 porcelain pan is not suitable for high heat conditions. If the heat is too high, it may bend and get damaged. 

Pros

Cons

Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminum Cooking Pan

The highlight of the Handi-foil pan is that it is disposable. All you need to do is use and throw away. This makes it really suitable for outdoor usage as you really don’t need to go through the stress of securing a place for storage purposes. 

The Handi-Foil Disposable Aluminium Foil Broiler pan also comes in different packages such as 10, 25, 100, and 200 to give you different options to choose from.

It serves a dual purpose function of broiling and baking, which allows you to bake and broil according to your meals’ suitable preparation demands. 

It is also equipped with a disposable drain pain that accommodates drips and can be disposed of after use.

The only downside to using the Handi-foil design is that it can’t accommodate heavy-weight food because its disposable design is fragile. 

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The handi-foil disposable aluminum broiler pan is convenient; go to the broiler pan during your outdoor gathering. It saves you the stress of storage and offers a wide range of package options to suit your needs. It is highly recommended if you aim to broil more conveniently outside the house. 

Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Steel Roaster

The Farberware nonstick broiler pan is among the top 8 best broiler pan of 2022 with a rack. This is primarily because it is equipped with unique features that set it apart from other broiler pans. 

For example, it comes with sturdy handles at both sides of the pan to ensure you have a firm grasp of your meal.

Its external and internal side is non –stick, so you can wash your broiler pan easily when you have done broiling. 

The Farberware is further equipped with a heavy carbon stick gauge that ensures it doesn’t get warped or damaged whenever it is under intense heat level.

The downside I discovered about the Farbeware 11 by 15 nonstick broiler pan is that its rotating handle might not be safe to hold when it’s hot.

Pros

Cons

Takeaway 

The Farbeware 11 by 15 nonstick broiler pan is a great choice if you love to have a firm grasp of your meal during carriage and if you want a long-lasting experience with your broiler pan as it doesn’t warp under intense heat conditions.  

Buying Guide to The Best Broiler Pans of 2022

To get the best results with your broiler pans, there are certain factors to put into consideration. Below, I listed the important factors to look out for. 

Type of Food 

When buying broiler pans, you should consider the type of meals you want to prepare or the type of food you prepare the most. Broiler pans are designed for broiling varying types of food. For instance, some people go for the best broiler pans to broil steaks and traditional broiler pans for beefsteaks. 

However, many types of broiler pans broil more than beefsteaks, such as pork chops, fish fillets, chicken cutlets, and tons of other foods. 

Therefore, ensure you know the type of food you want to broil, and ensure the broiler pan you are about to purchase can broil the food. 

Size of Broiler Pan 

You need to determine the right size of pan you need before opting for a broiler pan. One way to determine the right size of broiler pan you need is by checking your oven size as the size of broiler you go for must fit your oven size and shape.

For instance, if the shape of your oven is rectangular, then you should be on the look-out for a broiler pan that is rectangular in shape. 

Also, if your oven is round-shaped, then you should ultimately opt for a round-shaped broiler pan. 

To can take a step further by measuring the size of your oven to be sure of accurate size. 

Material 

There are two reasons why this is an important factor to note when purchasing your broiler pan. First, materials have different resistance to heat pressure. Therefore, if you purchase material with inferior quality material, it may warp under intense heat pressure.

Secondly, the type of material used would determine if your broiler pan would be easy to clean and maintain. 

For instance, a Teflon coated broiler pan would be easier to clean because it is nonstick. Also, broiler pan materials that are dishwasher friendly would be easy to clean and maintain, and the ones that not might be difficult to clean, which is why it’s important to look out for the right type of material when making your next purchase.

FAQs

Below, I answered your most frequently asked questions about broiler pans. 

What are Pans Safe for Broiler? 

Sturdy metal plans are the best recommendations for broiling. Using a different type of broiler, such as glass metal pans, may damage the broiling process. 

What is the Purpose of a Broiler Pan? 

A broiler pan is basically used for broiling food. 

What Food Do You Broil? 

You can broil different food types ranging from chicken cutlets, fish fillets, pork chops, steaks, and many others. 

How Do I Know When My Broiler Is Ready?

You can know if your meal is ready by using a meat thermometer. If you notice the top of your meat is brown already, but the center is undone, take the rack away from where the meat is and continue broiling. The idea is to ensure both the surface and inner part of your meat is well cooked. 

Summary 

It’s important to know the best broiler to buy to achieve the best results when you broil, which is why I reviewed the top 8 best broiler pans of 2022 in this article, as well as a buying guide to help you through your purchase.